Folding hands in prayer

Sign in English Us



Folding hands in prayer

5906 0  share 3

The folding of hands in front by one who is praying is considered an innovation (bid'a) and is forbidden in lmami fiqh. Imam 'Ali said:

'The Muslim should not fold his hands in front of him while praying, standing before God; [for, should he do so] he would be like the disbelieving fire-worshippers. [1]

Abu Hamid al-Sa'adi, a great companion, reported in front of a group of other companions-including such figures as Abu Hurayra, Sahl Sa'adi, Abu Usayd Sa'adi, Abu Qutada, Harith b. Rub'i and Muhammad b. Muslima-the precise manner in which the Prophet prayed, naming all the most subtle as well as the most basic recommended practices; but he said nothing about such a practice as the folding of one's hands in front of one.[2]
It is clear, then, that if the Prophet had prayed in such a manner, even occasionally, he [Abu Hamid al-Sa'adi] would have mentioned it, or at least, those present would have done so. Similar hadiths to this one have been transmitted to us from Imam Sadiq, through Hammad b. 'Isa, and are recorded in our books of Hadith.[3]

We can also usefully take note of the hadith of Sahl b. Sa'd which tells us, implicitly, that the folding of the hands in the prayer came about after the Prophet's death. He said: 'The people were ordered to do so '[4] if this action were ordered by the Prophet, the order would have been explicitly connected to him .

1. al-'Amili, Wasa'il al-Shi'a, vol. 4, ch. 15, hadith no. 7.
2. al-Bayhaqi, Sunan, vol. 2, pp. 72, 73, 101, 102; Abu Dawud, Sunan, vol, 1, p. 196, hadith no. 730,736; Tirmidhi, Sunan, v.2, p.98
3. al-'Amili, Wasa'il al-Shi a, 4, ch. 1, hadith no. 8 1.
4. al-'Asqalani, Fath al-bari", vol. 2, p. 224; Bayhaqi, Sunan, vol. 2, p. 28.

Related Post

The Prophet of Morality

The Prophet of Morality

One day when the Prophet and his companions were crossing a desert, they decided...

Discussions Concerning Imam Mahdi

Discussions Concerning Imam Mahdi

Al-Mahdi, the promised one, is from the family of the Prophet and a descendent o...

Permanency of ethical values

Permanency of ethical values

Ethical values, which pertain to the very principle of humanity, and which are t...

Imam Hassan al-Askari and the Christian Rain-Maker (story)

Imam Hassan al-Askari and the Christian Rain-Maker...

In the time of our 11th Imam, Imam Hasan al-Askari (A) there was a drought in Ba...

Join Us For a Simple Meal (story)

Join Us For a Simple Meal (story)

Our 2nd Imam, Imam Hasan (A) was always very kind to the poor. One day, the Imam...

Why do the Shiites believe in the infallibility of their Imams?

Why do the Shiites believe in the infallibility of...

In order to prove the infallibility of the Imams, Shiite theologians have put fo...

Degrees of the oneness of God 1 (Oneness of the Essence)

Degrees of the oneness of God 1 (Oneness of the Es...

All divinely revealed religions are based on Tawhid, that is, the Oneness of God...

The intelligibility of good and evil (husn wa qubh aqli)

The intelligibility of good and evil (husn wa qubh...

All Muslims are at one over the issue of divine justice; but there is a certain ...

Comments

Please share your comments with us.

0 Comments

Blog Categories

IslamPlus Events Article Ahlulbayt View